Categories
ATVR Reviews Midwest Video Productions

UP and CNW on The Geneva Sub Volume 1, East of Geneva

Producer: MVP

Locations: West Chicago, Wheaton, Geneva

Timeframe: 1996

Length: 1 hour 25 minutes

Source: Robert Calvert

Union Pacific’s route out of Chicago. This was Chicago & NorthWestern. Originally this release was an MVP Production. This current version is also labeled as a Highball show.

A single DVD-R. Older camcorder video source. Appearance is similar to other MVP shows that were shot in the 1990s. Historical value, which is not to modern standards. Live environmental audio exceeds the video quality and sounds great. Clear narrative by Robert Calvert is above the train sounds.

No chapter menu. Data screens convey additional information. Narrated with varying details on train movements.

Progression of coverage is noted on data screens. No maps. West Chicago has plenty of rail traffic.

To the Trains… 👉

Geneva

Begins on April 27, 1996. Geneva NorthWestern Bridge for the Fox River Crossing. Eastbound DMPR-A towards Proviso Yard. More freights are shown here. Too bad the visuals are lacking clarity. The train sounds are excellent.

JB Tower

JB Tower at West Chicago is next. CNW 8603 leads Westbound empty hoppers that originated from Detroit Edison on Grand Trunk. Note the tower in the background. The interesecting rails are EJ&E.

JB Tower

Union Pacific 9482 backs a Coal Train onto EJ&E. Nice view of JB Tower in this frame.

SD40-2 6840

At West Chicago. CNW 6840 leads a pair of leased units on symbol MAPR. Mixed freight. Routed from Madison, Iowa to Proviso Yard.

CHMI-V is a vehicle train from Chicago to Milpitas, California. CNW engine 6907 (SD40-2) is on the point at West Chicago.

844

Union Pacific Challenger 844 is seen at West Chicago hauling a special in August, 1996. This steam engine makes another appearance later on.

UP 8043

Union Pacific SD90MACs are new. Eastbound at West Chicago.

Metra 144

Wheaton with Metra Commuters.

Flames at the stack on a CNW trailing locomotive! More night scenes than needed, this one is worthy on a priority APL move to Los Angeles. The others are quite dark and below average.

Proviso Yard

A CNW GP7 4126 switches at Proviso Yard.

UP and CNW on The Geneva Sub Volume 1, East of Geneva

CNW fans should be pleased at the large percentage of unmolested locomotives still at large. Union Pacific had a Chicago area presence of run through power for years, preceeding the merger. The downside is longing for higher quality images.

Editing has a clumsy overall feel. The cuts seem abrupt. Fades and resumes often take just a little too long. Hence, loose and jumpy.

Narrative is good. Soundtrack is fine. Data screens are effective, when used.

The mediocre visuals keep this show rating low. Best suited for hardcore Railfans or maybe some foamers.

Rating: 2 1/2 Stars

William J. Hudson's avatar

By William J. Hudson

I am a creative man.
Writing is enjoyable.
There are my current internet features.
American Train Video Reviews is worldwide,
.
A musician for many years. Guitar is my main instrument. Enjoy bass playing .Rock and Blues styles. However, Lead Vocals have been a Huge surprise!
The crowd loves my singing. I sound like; Joe Cocker, Greg Allman, with a bluesy tone. Nobody was more shocked than me. A late bloomer.

I love to have some laughs. People think that I am hilarious, and I remain clueless as to why... :)

I hope that everyone enjoys the material.

Leave a comment